Needs, activities and results
A report may count distributed kits without showing whether households received them on time or use them. Activities describe work done; outcomes describe a change, such as more consistent access to a service. Wider impacts and their causes require stronger evidence.
Read evaluation criteria in context
The OECD distinguishes relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact and sustainability. Ask whether the response fits needs, complements other actors, achieves objectives and uses resources appropriately. Immediate relief and recovery programmes have different continuity requirements.
Costs without a magic ratio
Compare similar accounting boundaries and periods. Security, training, monitoring, logistics and abuse prevention contribute to quality. A single ratio does not tell you who was excluded, what risks were reduced or how long a service worked.
How can affected people respond?
The CHS 2024 centres people and communities in quality. Look for understandable information, meaningful participation, a safe complaint channel and examples of changes following feedback. Distinguish a published policy from evidence of implementation.
An explicitly fictional reading example
Teaching example: 100 kits given to 100 households are an output. Follow-up with 60 households does not automatically describe all 100. Ask why 40 were not reached, what was asked and which adverse effects were examined. This scenario is not any organization’s reported performance.
Reported funding is not final expenditure
FTS brings together funding reported by humanitarian actors and tracks it against response-plan requirements. It also includes funding outside appeals. A coverage percentage therefore describes a plan, a period and recorded reports; it measures neither money received by each household nor aid quality.
Keep the access date, plan and its reference funding requirement. Do not mix funding for a plan with funding outside it. A flow may pass through a donor, a fund and a partner: adding these stages as independent contributions can count the same money more than once.
OCHA — Financial Tracking Service guidance · Official source ·
Do more interventions mean more people supported?
Illustrative fictional scenario: A report shows increased interventions by counting repeat visits to the same households, while the earlier report counted unique people. The increase cannot directly be interpreted as wider coverage.
Ask for the indicator’s definition, unit, period and methodological changes. Distinguish activity, effective access and observed change, then review limitations and feedback from affected people. If comparison remains impossible, present the results separately. A positive result does not establish that the programme alone caused all the change.
Core Humanitarian Standard 2024 · Official source ·
Observed change can have several causes
Results may depend on other interventions, changing markets or starting conditions. A credible evaluation explains plausible mechanisms and alternative explanations. Before-and-after comparison alone is not automatic evidence of causation.
- Population: ask who remained in the sample.
- Context: identify external changes.
- Interpretation: distinguish contribution from attribution.
An external evaluation alone proves neither independence nor methodological strength.
OECD · Evaluation criteria · Official source ·
Your reading checklist
- 1
Define your question
Which need, population, area and period do you want to assess?
- 2
Gather evidence
Read activity reports, financial statements, evaluations and methods; note missing information.
- 3
Decide and review
Ask the official service your questions and reassess when new findings are published.
Mistakes to avoid
- Confusing distributions with unique people.
- Comparing ratios without knowing accounting boundaries.
- Treating missing public evaluation as proof of fraud.
Frequently asked questions
Is an annual report enough?
It provides an initial picture. An evaluation, its method and people’s feedback help explain results and limitations.
Should I choose the lowest administrative costs?
This criterion alone measures neither relevance nor quality. Also consider safety, access, results and monitoring responsibilities.
Does a label replace this reading?
A label has a scope and a date. Check its coverage and examine programme-specific results as well.
Official sources
Always verify the date and conditions on the official source.
Organisations and resources to explore
These examples relate to the topic through their documented activities. They are neither a ranking nor a guarantee of availability; check each organisation’s terms and requirements.

Evidence Aid
Documentary resource — charity closed
The Evidence Aid charity closed on 31 October 2024. The International Rescue Committee now hosts the website and keeps much of its existing material publicly accessible.
View directory record →
Elrha
Elrha funds research and innovation to improve humanitarian response, including water and hygiene, inclusion, mental health and locally led innovation.
View directory record →
H2H Network
H2H brings together specialist providers supporting humanitarian actors through data, community engagement, quality, security and logistics. Its fund finances services delivered by network members.
View directory record →
ALIMA
In its 2025 annual report, ALIMA presents medical responses during crises and associated research. The report lets readers trace the projects and results the organization published for that reporting year.
View directory record →